Question
Did Dr. Sadao do his duty honestly? Explain your answer with suitable reasons.

Answer

1. Honesty Toward His Profession (The Doctor's Duty)
As a surgeon, Dr. Sadao’s primary duty was to save a dying life, regardless of the person's identity.
- Saving the Enemy: Despite knowing that the man was an American prisoner of war (an enemy of Japan), Sadao could not let him die. He said, "If he were a well man I could turn him over to the police... but since he is wounded..."
- Operating Under Stress: He operated on the soldier with great precision, even when his servants revolted and left the house. His commitment to the "Hippocratic Oath" (the oath of doctors) was absolute.
- Personal Care: He and his wife, Hana, fed and nursed the soldier back to health, showing that his honesty as a doctor was not just about surgery but also about the recovery of the patient.
2. Honesty Toward His Country (The Citizen's Duty)
Dr. Sadao was not a traitor. He did not hide the American soldier because of a lack of patriotism.
- Confessing to the General: He acted honestly as a Japanese citizen by informing the General about the presence of the white man in his house. He told the General everything, effectively putting his own life and reputation at risk.
- Waiting for the Assassins: He agreed to the General’s plan to send private assassins to kill the soldier. He kept the outer partition of the soldier's room open for three nights, waiting for the killers. This shows he was willing to let his country take charge of the "enemy."
3. The Moral Resolution
When the General forgot to send the assassins due to his own illness, Sadao faced a dilemma. To save his family from further danger and to save his own conscience, he helped the soldier escape.
- He provided the soldier with a boat, food, and clothing.
- He gave him instructions on how to reach a nearby island and signal for help.

Need a full question paper?

Generate a complete, print-ready paper with questions like this in minutes — across 16+ boards, with answer keys.

Start Generating Free

Similar questions

Giving a bribe is an evil practice. How did the Tiger King bribe the British officer to save his kingdom? How do you view this act of his?
Both the general (The Enemy) and the Maharaja (The Tiger King), deal with death. They are powerful figures confronted by a similar fate. You wish to include both of these characters in an upcoming play. As a part of your research essay, compare and contrast their experiences and their responses to these experiences in 120–150 words. [Clue: Include the similarities and differences of their circumstances - their way of dealing with things - their ultimate fate]
Do you think Tiger King’s life would have taken a different course if he had not heard the prophecy about his future? What kind of a king would he have proved to be?
How would you evaluate Sam’s character? Elucidate any two qualities, and substantiate them with evidence from the text.
‘I shall cut my tuft ,crop my hair short and become an insurance agent'. Explain the context.
Why do you think Charley withdrew nearly all the money he had from the bank to buy old-style currency?
Describe the third level as a science fantasy?
In his letter to Charley, Sam writes, ‘…then I got to believing you were right.’ What could have made Sam begin to believe?
At the beginning of the story, Sam is skeptical of Charley’s discovery of the third level. By the end of the story, the reader is told that he found the third level and traveled back in time. How would Sam diagnose himself?
What is the significance of the title ‘Journey to the End of the Earth’?