Question
"Government debt is a burden " - Analyze this statement giving arguments for and against.

Answer

Government debt (Public Debt) refers to the total amount of money borrowed by the government to meet its expenditures when its revenue falls short. Whether this debt is a "burden" is a subject of debate among economists.
Arguments FOR the Statement (Debt as a Burden) :
1. Future Tax Burden : To repay the debt and interest, the government may increase taxes in the future. This reduces the disposable income of future generations.
2. Crowding Out Effect : High government borrowing reduces the funds available for private investment. This can lead to higher interest rates, slowing down private sector growth.
3. Inflationary Pressure : If the government prints more money to repay the debt, it leads to inflation, reducing the purchasing power of the people.
4. Dependence on Foreign Powers : If the debt is taken from foreign countries or international
organizations (External Debt), it may lead to economic and political interference by those entities.
Arguments AGAINST the Statement (Debt as a Necessity/Benefit) :
1. Productive Investment : If the borrowed money is used to build infrastructure (roads, bridges, schools), it creates assets that generate future income and boost GDP.
2. Economic Stability : During a recession, the government borrows to spend on public welfare, which increases demand and helps the economy recover.
3. No Burden if Internal : If the debt is "Internal Debt" (borrowed from its own citizens), the money stays within the country; it is simply a transfer of wealth from one section to another.
4. Social Welfare : Debt allows the government to fund essential services like healthcare and education without waiting for immediate tax revenue.
Conclusion : Debt is not necessarily a burden if managed wisely. If used for capital formation (productive purposes), it helps the economy grow. However, if used for consumption expenditure, it becomes a heavy burden for future generations.

Need a full question paper?

Generate a complete, print-ready paper with questions like this in minutes — across 16+ boards, with answer keys.

Start Generating Free

Similar questions

From the following table, calculate price at each level of output.
Output(Units) 1 2 3 4
Marginal Revenue(₹) 6 4 2 0
Explain with the help of a diagram the effect of the following changes on the demand of a commodity.
  1. A fall in the price of substitute good.
  2. A fall in the income of its buyer.
Market for a good is in equilibrium. There is 'increase' in supply of the good. Explain the chain of effects of this change. Use diagram.
Explain the ‘expenditure’ method of estimating national income.
What changes will take place to bring an economy in equilibrium if
  1. Planned savings are greater than planned investment and
  2. Planned savings are less than planned investment.
When the price of a good rises from ₹ 10 per unit to ₹ 12 per unit, its quantity demanded falls by 20 percent. Calculate its price elasticity of demand. How much would be the percentage change in its quantity demanded, if the price rises from ₹ 10 per unit to ₹ 13 per unit?
Given saving curve, derive consumption curve and state the steps in doing so. Use diagram.
Explain the implications of the following in an oligopoly market:
  1. Inter-dependence between firms.
  2. Non-price competition.
State the behaviour of marginal product in the law of variable proportions. Explain the causes of this behaviour.

OR

Giving reasons, explain the law of variable proportion.

OR

 What are the different phases in the Law of Variable Proportions in terms of marginal product? Give reason behind each phase. Use diagram.

What are revenue receipts? Explain the role of government budget in bringing stability in the economy.