Question
For sound waves, the Doppler formula for frequency shift differs slightly between the two situations: (i) source at rest; observer moving, and (ii) source moving; observer at rest. The exact Doppler formulas for the case of light waves in vacuum are, however, strictly identical for these situations. Explain why this should be so. Would you expect the formulas to be strictly identical for the two situations in case of light travelling in a medium?

Answer

Sound waves require a medium for propagation. Thus, even though both the situations may correspond to the same relative motion (between the source and the observer), they are not identical physically since, the motion of the observer, relative to the medium is different in the two situations. Therefore, we cannot expect Doppler formulas for sound to be identical for (i) and (ii).
For light waves in vacuum, there is clearly nothing to distinguish between two cases given. Here only the relative motion between the source and the observer counts and the relativistic Doppler formula is the same for both cases. For light propagation in a medium, once again like for sound waves, the two situations are not identical and we should expect the Doppler formulas for this case to be different for the two situations (i) and (ii).

Need a full question paper?

Generate a complete, print-ready paper with questions like this in minutes — across 16+ boards, with answer keys.

Start Generating Free

Similar questions

A parallel-plate capacitor with plate area 20cm2 and plate separation 1.0mm is connected to a battery. The resistance of the circuit is $10\text{k}\Omega.$ Find the time constant of the circuit.
In a hydrogen atom, the electron and proton are bound at a distance of about 0.53 $\mathring{\text{A}}$:
  1. Estimate the potential energy of the system in eV, taking the zero of the potential energy at infinite separation of the electron from proton.
  2. What is the minimum work required to free the electron, given that its kinetic energy in the orbit is half the magnitude of potential energy obtained in (a)?
  3. What are the answers to (a) and (b) above if the zero of potential energy is taken at 1.06 Å separation?
The figure below shows the $\text{V-I}$ characteristic of a semiconductor diode.

 

  1. Identify the semiconductor diode used.
  2. Draw the circuit diagram to obtain the given characteristic of this device.
  3. Briefly, explain how this diode can be used as a voltage regulator.
A cell of emf 'E' and internal resistance 'r' is connected across a variable load resistor R. Draw the plots of the terminal voltage V versus (i) R and (ii) the current I.
It is found that when R = 4$\Omega$, the current is 1 A and when R is increased to 9$\Omega$, the current reduces to 0.5 A. Find the values of the emf E and internal resistance r.
You are given two circuits (a) and (b) as shown in the figures, which consist of NAND gates. Identify the logic operation carried out by the two. Write the truth tables for each. Identify the gates equivalent to the two circuits.

A metal wire PQ of mass 10g lies at rest on two horizontal metal rails separated by 4.90cm A vertically-downward magnetic field of magnitude 0.800T exists in the space. The resistance of the circuit is slowly decreased and it is found that when the resistance goes below 20.0Ω, the wire PQ starts sliding on the rails. Find the coefficient of friction.

A cylindrical metallic wire is stretched to increase its length by 10%. Calculate the percentage increase in its resistance.
Calculate the de Broglie wavelength of a neutron of kinetic energy 150eV. Mass of neutron = 1.67 × 10-27kg.
Suppose an attractive nuclear force acts between two protons which may be written as $\text{F}=\text{Ce}^{-\text{kr}}/\text{r}^2.$
  1. Write down the dimensional formulae and appropriate SI units of C and k.
  2. Suppose that k = 1 fermi-1 and that the repulsive electric force between the protons is just balanced by the attractive nuclear force when the separation is 5 fermi. Find the value of C.
Compute the typical de Broglie wavelength of an electron in a metal at 27ºC and compare it with the mean separation between two electrons in a metal which is given to be about 2 × 10–10 m.