Question 13 Marks
Deuteron is a bound state of a neutron and a proton with a binding energy $B =2.2 MeV. A \gamma-$ ray of energy $E$ is aimed at a deuteron nucleus to try to break it into a $($neutron $+$ proton$)$ such that the $n$ and $p$ move in the direction of the incident $\gamma-$ ray. If $E = B$, show that this cannot happen. Hence calculate how much bigger than $B$ must $E$ be for such a process to happen.
Answer
View full question & answer→Binding energy of a deuteron is, $B=2.2 MeV$
Let kinetic energy and the momentum of neutron and proton be $K _n, K_{ p }$, and $P _n, P _{ p }$ respectively.
From the conservation of energy,
$E - B = K _{ n }+ K _{ p }=\frac{p_m^2}{2 m}+\frac{p_p^2}{2 m}$
Now applying conservation of momentum is given by,
$ Pn _{ n }+ p _{ p }=\frac{E}{C}$
$As E = B , Eq . \text { (i) } p_n^2+p_p^2=0$
It only happens if $p _{ n }= p _{ p }$
So, the Eq. $(ii)$ cannot be satisfied and the process cannot take place.
Let us take $E = B + x$, where $x << B$ for the process to take place.
Putting the value of $p _{ n }$ from Eq. $(ii)$ in Eq. $(i),$ we get
or $2 p_p^2-\left(\frac{2 E}{c}\right) p_p+\left(\frac{E^2}{c^2}-2 m x\right)=0$
Solving the quadratic equation, we get
$P _{ p }=\frac{\frac{2 E}{c}+\sqrt{\frac{4 E^2}{c^2}-8\left(\frac{E^2}{c^2}-2 m x\right)}}{4}$
For the real value $p _{ p }$, the discriminant is positive,
Hence
$\frac{4 E^2}{c^2}=8\left(\frac{E^2}{c^2}-2 m x\right)$
$16 mx =\frac{4 E^2}{c^2} $
$\Rightarrow x=\frac{E^2}{4 m c^2}$
But $ X \ll B ,$ hence $ E \ll B$
$\Rightarrow x=\frac{B^2}{4 m c^2}$
Let kinetic energy and the momentum of neutron and proton be $K _n, K_{ p }$, and $P _n, P _{ p }$ respectively.
From the conservation of energy,
$E - B = K _{ n }+ K _{ p }=\frac{p_m^2}{2 m}+\frac{p_p^2}{2 m}$
Now applying conservation of momentum is given by,
$ Pn _{ n }+ p _{ p }=\frac{E}{C}$
$As E = B , Eq . \text { (i) } p_n^2+p_p^2=0$
It only happens if $p _{ n }= p _{ p }$
So, the Eq. $(ii)$ cannot be satisfied and the process cannot take place.
Let us take $E = B + x$, where $x << B$ for the process to take place.
Putting the value of $p _{ n }$ from Eq. $(ii)$ in Eq. $(i),$ we get
or $2 p_p^2-\left(\frac{2 E}{c}\right) p_p+\left(\frac{E^2}{c^2}-2 m x\right)=0$
Solving the quadratic equation, we get
$P _{ p }=\frac{\frac{2 E}{c}+\sqrt{\frac{4 E^2}{c^2}-8\left(\frac{E^2}{c^2}-2 m x\right)}}{4}$
For the real value $p _{ p }$, the discriminant is positive,
Hence
$\frac{4 E^2}{c^2}=8\left(\frac{E^2}{c^2}-2 m x\right)$
$16 mx =\frac{4 E^2}{c^2} $
$\Rightarrow x=\frac{E^2}{4 m c^2}$
But $ X \ll B ,$ hence $ E \ll B$
$\Rightarrow x=\frac{B^2}{4 m c^2}$


